It was very warm — a good day to be a speaker, and have a seat in the shade. That’s John Land in the hat.
Well, to begin with, Fritz Hollings didn’t make it to the 2014 Galivants Ferry Stump Speaking, which he has been attending as long as I’ve been alive. He called Russell Holliday, who puts on the event started by her ancestors 138 years ago, late this morning to describe rather frankly an unpleasant side effect he was having from a new medication, and to explain he’d have to miss it.
Which was a disappointment. But there was still the keynote speaker, SC native and MSNBC commentator Jimmy Williams. And there were the candidates, with gubernatorial candidate Vincent Sheheen at the top of the ticket.
But there was a serious lack of attendees. And on a less notable level, a lack of energy, and a lack of ideas. I hate to say this because I know Russell works very hard to bring this event off, and I’m here to say that she and her family did as good a job as ever. All the pieces were there — people just had to show up and inspire. The fault lay with the candidates. I just didn’t feel the same spirit that I’ve felt at earlier stumps. Sure, there was Fritz on those occasions, and there was usually another draw such as Joe Biden (see Fritz introducing him at this event in 2006), making SC Democrats feel that while they might be beleaguered here in South Carolina, they were part of something vital nationally.
To his credit, Vincent Sheheen showed more fire and energy than I’ve seen from him yet (if the video ever finishes uploading to YouTube, I’ll show you). But the substance was lacking. He ran through the usual litany of complaints about Nikki Haley (the Department of Revenue breach, her refusal to expand Medicaid) and then said he hadn’t come to talk about the last four years, but the next four — which raised my hopes.
“Without a vision, the people perish,” he said, citing Proverbs. But the vision was… skimpy. Four-year-old kindergarten, Medicaid expansion, fixing up infrastructure — each with about one sentence devoted to it.
And then, suddenly, the five-minute address was over.
OK, the Stump is a party, not an occasion for extended oration. Still, I was disappointed.
And the disappointment extended across the spectrum. When Sen. Brad Hutto strung together a series of populist bromides about how that Lindsey Graham needed to stop worrying about the rest of the world and fix some potholes in good ol’ SC — as though he were running for county council rather than the United States Senate — we had reached the nadir. One hopes. I didn’t stay for the last of the down-the-ballot speakers.
Rhetorically, I think the high point came at the beginning, when young Johnson Holliday of Russell’s clan quoted Texan Jim Hightower saying “Everybody does better when everybody does better.”
Now that I could go for. That was a concept that would have been worth enlarging upon.
Sure, I like the communitarian overtones, but think about it: The saying not only states what Democrats believe in, but in a way that it’s hard for Republicans to argue with, and that could appeal to independents (like yours truly). After all, it’s not all that far conceptually from the Republicans’ “A rising tide lifts all boats.”
The thing that will lift this country out of the doldrums, and SC out of the back-of-the-line status that has plagued it in one way or another since 1865, is growth — growth in jobs and wages as well as in profits, productivity and innovation.
Surely there’s someone in the Democratic Party — or some party — who could take a concept like that and run with it. If that happened, we’d have some Stump meetings that everybody would want to attend, like in the old days, when everybody was a Democrat, and this was the place to be every two years.
Editor’s note: As I finish this, YouTube is telling me there are another 85 minutes to go before the Sheheen video finishes loading. If it loads — and a long upload like this often ends in tears of frustration — I’ll share it with you in the morning. In the meantime, enjoy the stills.
-
- Vincent’s dad, Fred Sheheen.
-
- SC Democratic Party Chairman Jaime Harrison
-
- Bakari Sellers and Vincent Sheheen applauding as candidates were introduced.
-
- I didn’t ask, but I’m pretty sure this guy was also a Democrat.
-
- With Russell Holliday, who did a great job as always hosting the event. If only there’d been better candidates.
-
- Vincent evinces fire in the belly.
-
- The national anthem.
-
- The crowd, which was fairly sparse this year.
-
- Keynote speaker Jimmy Williams.
Related Posts
Nice post. Looks like you may have a knack for this journalist thing.
Brace yourself for the Harrell decision comments tomorrow.
Bromide: definition “a trite and unoriginal idea or remark, typically intended to soothe or placate.
Feel-good bromides create the illusion of problem solving.” Example: ““Everybody does better when everybody does better.”
How about “Everybody does better when everybody works hard, is honest, and contributes” instead? And, in reality, we already have that trite truism in effect. Everybody does better right now because a certain group of people innovate, produce profits, and are productive. Obamacare wouldn’t exist unless productive people and people responsible for creating profits were forced to redistribute the results of their efforts back to some people who do little or nothing. Subsidies and Medicaid are examples of everyone doing better. If you REALLY want everyone to do better, remove the barriers that hold back productive people. Stop rewarding people who aren’t.