Cross my fingers and hope not to lie...
A month or so ago, a couple of friends brought my attention to a contest that The Washington Post was having to find America’s Next Great Pundit.
There were a lot of reasons not to enter. For one thing, I doubted they wanted an actual professional journalist. For another, the contest rules were reminiscent of a Reality TV game show, rather than the more dignified process for choosing op-ed material to which I was accustomed. Then, there was the fact that you could only submit one opinion piece, and it had to be less than 400 words. That last one was a killer. Yes, I can do Twitter, which means that in a pinch I can express myself in 140 characters (it would be strange if I couldn’t, after all those decades of headline-writing). But “pundits” write columns. And 400 words do not a column make. My own columns in The State were on the long side — around 1,000 words (I was the editor, so I made the room). A typical column in The Washington Post runs close to 750 words. In 400 words, you have no room to develop a topic, support it with argument, and throw in grace notes (the digressions that I love) that make the piece worth reading. (Interesting side note: The official rules of the Post‘s contest ran 3,883 words — almost 10 times the limit those very rules required me to stay within.)
But I entered anyway, grumbling all the way. And here’s the piece I entered:
The first casualty of unemployment is the truth.
OK, maybe not the first. First there’s the blow to one’s bank account. Then the loss of self-confidence. But truth is right up there. Especially for me. Until I was laid off in March, I was editorial page editor of South Carolina’s largest newspaper. A colleague once said to me, accusingly, “You don’t think this is the opinion page. You think it’s the truth page.” I just looked at her blankly. Of course it was the truth page.
Readers expected me to tell everything I knew, and plenty that I only thought I knew – about South Carolina’s feckless politicians (Mark Sanford, Joe Wilson – need I say more?), or whatever struck me, without reservation. And I delivered.
My reputation survives my career. Recently, a friend warned me that people feel constrained in talking to me, because their confidences might turn up on my blog. After all, bloggers tell all, right? Ask Monica Lewinsky. Ask ACORN.
“HAH!” say I.
As a blogger who answers to no one, I am not nearly as frank and open as I was as a newspaper editor who thought he had a secure job.
I haven’t disclosed whom I have worked for on consulting gigs since leaving the paper, because my clients haven’t been crazy about the exposure. Every word I write, I think: Might this put off a prospective employer? And I know it has, despite my caution.
There are things I have not written – pithy, witty, dead-on observations on the passing parade, I assure you – because I think, “Do you have to write that and run the risk of offending this person who MIGHT point you to a job? Can’t you just write about something else?”
And where am I applying for jobs? Well, I’m not going to tell YOU, am I?
People used to praise me for my courage for taking on powerful people at the paper. But I was taking no risk whatsoever. As long as I was supported by advertising, a transaction I was ethically barred from even thinking about, I had impunity.
But an unaligned blogger still trying to function as a journalist stands naked and alone, and is not nearly as free and honest as he was writing from the once-impregnable citadel of an editorial page. At least, this one isn’t. Keep that in mind, citizen, as newspapers fall around you.
That piece was 399 words. It didn’t make the cut, which didn’t surprise me. I wouldn’t have wanted to publish that little chopped-down fragment, either. It never had the chance to get rolling and get interesting.
But I offer it here because I wanted to share the point of the piece with you — the fact that a lone blogger, if he hopes to find employment anywhere, is a lot more constrained than a journalist who is paid a good salary to write his honest opinion about anything and everything without consideration of where the chips fall.
Sure, there were constraints in being the editorial page editor that I don’t feel now. For instance, I had to keep in mind that I should not embarrass my colleagues, or put them in an awkward spot. I think Cindi and Warren (and Mike and Nina, back when I had a full staff) would have felt a little uncomfortable, for instance, with my honest assessment of the intellectual capacities of the candidates for governor. They might have felt like it made the paper look like it wasn’t considering the candidates with an open mind. It wouldn’t have meant that, because I change my mind about candidates all the time (and besides, as I said in that post, intellect isn’t everything in a candidate). But because I was the editorial page editor, they would have worried about the appearance of the thing. And they might have talked me out of it, even as a blog post. And I almost certainly would not have written it in a column at this stage in the campaign.
So it cuts both ways.
But I feel far more constraint out here alone and naked, without the salary and license I had. In fact, I am acutely aware that the very fact that I blog and express opinions at all is a huge turnoff to some employers, including some for whom I’d like to work. I keep blogging anyway (my attitude is, I can stop the minute you hire me, if that’s what you want; in the meantime, it keeps my name out there), and I pretty much always shrug off my misgivings and go ahead and say what I think anyway, but I do have that hesitation that I never had before. This matters because any journalistic process involves, at its first stage, deciding what to write about. And that entails deciding not to write about the rest of the universe. And what I can’t tell you for sure — to what extent is any of us totally honest with himself about his own motives? — is to what extent that extremely complex process is or is not influenced by my concerns about putting food on the table and paying the mortgage.
About all I can do is cross my fingers and hope not to lie. And I wanted to disclose that.