There was a thought-provoking little piece in the WSJ today by a bookstore owner in Tennessee:
The weather in Tennessee has been unaccountably beautiful this summer, with late July temperatures in the 70s rather than the 100s. The drive from Chattanooga, where President Obama gave his jobs speech at the Amazon warehouse Tuesday, to Nashville, where I am the co-owner of Parnassus Books, is a scenic two hours.
I wish he’d come by.
Thanks to the Amazon warehouse, there are about 7,000 new jobs in Chattanooga, many of them seasonal. But to celebrate Amazon as an employer is to ignore all the jobs that have been squeezed out of the economy as independent bookstores and other small businesses have been forced to close their doors, unable to compete with the undercut pricing the online retail giant offers. And with those shuttered bookstores go a big part of our community.
In the time-honored tradition of bookstores everywhere, our store is staffed by readers—people who want to talk about the books they love. We’re not handing out algorithms based on what books other people have bought. These aren’t widgets we’re selling….
Actually, it was more of a feeling-provoking piece than thought-provoking, I suppose. And my feelings were conflicted.
First, I felt sympathy for the person trying to operate a mom-and-pop bookstore in this age. At the same time, I noticed that this person didn’t get into the business until 2011. A former editor of mine retired more than 10 years ago and started an online used book business, so it’s not like this phenomenon snuck up on this person. This is somewhat different from the character in “You’ve Got Mail” who inherited a charming little bookshop.
Second, I felt identification with someone who would rather browse books in person than buy one online. That happens to be one of my very favorite leisure-time activities, when I have leisure time. So it is that I continue to root for Barnes & Noble to hang in there with the real, live bookstore thing.
Third, I felt guilty because, well, as much as I love browsing a bookstore, I’ve always had a preference for Barnes & Noble over the charming little mom-and-pop types. Even though Rhett Jackson was a friend of mine, I seldom frequented his shop. If I went there, it was to quickly find a book and buy it. There’s something, for me, about having the vast space and great variety of B&N to wander in, while sipping a hot Starbucks coffee. (Here’s another confession: When I go to the one on Harbison, the one I frequent most, I actually go to the Starbucks over across the parking lot, rather than getting my coffee in the bookstore cafe. Partly because I can use my Starbucks card there.)
Of course, as I’ve confessed before, I usually don’t actually buy a book at the end of those browses. But when I do buy a book — as I did just this last weekend — I buy it at B&N.
Finally, I felt out-bookwormed by this woman. As you would expect from someone who sells new books, she’s very up-to-date in her reading. I seldom read a book that was written in the last 10 years, or even 50 years — there’s just too great a wealth of old stuff that I’ll never get to, I have little interest in keeping up with the best-seller lists. Since I started reading the daily book reviews in the WSJ, I have gotten a little more interested in recent books — but when I get one of them, it still tends to sit on my shelves for months or even years before I actually read it. I like to let them age a little. So much of the rest of my life has been spent keeping up with the latest, and meeting deadlines. Part of the pleasure of a book is knowing it will sit there and wait for me indefinitely, and be just as rewarding when I finally pick it up.
I use Amazon for all sorts of things. Particularly phone accessories — USB cords, earbuds — which are amazingly cheaper than in a store. Or when I’m shopping for some particular item someone wants for Christmas or birthday, and I don’t immediately find it in the first store where I look — I’ll just stand there in the store and order it over my phone.
But books I want to hold in my hand before I buy.
I used to enjoy going to B&N and hanging out, browsing and sampling books. Now I just
wait for the movie to come outbuy books on my Amazon Kindle. I don’t miss the bookstore much, and they tend to frown upon hanging out comfortably in your underwear, which I can do at home, with my Kindle.I loved an indie bookstore in Toco Hills shopping center near Emory, when I was in law school and finally, barely, able to afford new hardcover books. I got introduced to so many now-favorite authors there, including Jill McCorkle, who has a great new novel out. The chain stores seldom had much I wanted, back then, but the bigger ones do now, sometimes. Amazon just has more, and their algorithm works for me. I also get a lot of review copies as part of the Vine Program, which promotes many less-well known authors. They also reissue a lot of overlooked oldies….I love Amazon. Cheaper and better. I can make my own coffee, from organic beans bought from Amazon, ground in my burr grinder, from Amazon…..
I also use a Kindle. I find it easier to keep multiple books going at one time on the Kindle. Read a chapter of one, read a chapter of another. With my travel schedule, I don’t want to carry around multiple books.
That’s exactly why I got my Kindle. I got tired of lugging multiple books on trips. I had limited opportunity on my travels to restock, and I couldn’t bear to abandon books along the way…Then I updated to the Kindle FIre HD and am loving watching video on it.
Yes, I can see the appeal of a Kindle for a frequent traveler, though I would rather be finishing my eBook, downloaded on my recent foreign trip, in conventional form, instead of on my iPad mini. I understand the Kindle is lighter, though.
It’s interesting how few of the classics are in bookstores such as Barnes and Noble today. They have the basics – the best-known novels from, say, Tolstoy, Twain or Thackeray – but try finding lesser-known but still very good books by any of those authors and you’ll have to order them.
So much space is devoted to the book of the month, or week. Books that will mostly be all but forgotten in 10 years.
I make fresh-ground coffee at home, too (I have one of those things that automatically grinds and brews). But it’s not as good as what I can get at Starbucks, even though I use Starbucks beans at home. They’re just better at it.
Also, there’s the fact that I think the whole “I made it myself” satisfaction that we’re supposed to feel is overrated. I’m more like Yossarian, to cite one of my favorite books:
There are a lot of things about Yossarian that I thought were sort of shameful, if taken literally, when I first read the book, and that was one of them. But I have to admit that there’s some of that in me.
I’m that way about coffee, anyway. Coffee that other people make for me tastes, at least sometimes, better than that which I made myself.
I like Cafe Altura Columbian Dark Roast far better than Starbucks. The Tchibo coffee we got in Germany was even better….
I prefer Coca-Cola Classic, ice cold or on the rocks for my morning beverage.
Mountain Dew too much for ya?
Mountain Dew was my morning drug of choice from college years until recently. I’ve switched to Coca-Cola in the mornings now, and am stepping down further to green tea. Eventually. Some day. Probably after my son graduates from college.
Growing up we drank Coca Cola products, not Pepsi products, so I never really developed a taste for “the dew” but I’ll get it at a restaurant instead of Pepsi-Cola. Blech.
What about when you already know the book you want, and there’s no need to browse? Bookstores are great for browsing and passing time as a leisure activity, but I’m sure you’ve had an occasion where you absolutely know that you want to buy a certain book before you walked in the store. Do you go to a bookstore and buy it?
For instance, I knew that I wanted to buy the final book in Rick Atkinson’s “Liberation Trilogy”. I didn’t pay the higher price at a store. I got it for the best price on Amazon.
I buy fiction and very specific books. Amazon is indispensable for the latter, since few bookstores stock, for example, plan books of old farmhouses. The former, I just appreciate the lower cost of Amazon.
I do love the bookstore coffee smell. One reason to love the Woodhill Target….one more reason…..
There was a very funny line from the movie Matilda where Danny DeVito’s character told his bookworm daughter, Matilda, (paraphrasing) that he couldn’t understand why anyone would waste her time reading all those books while there was a perfectly good TV sitting in the living room. I read my fair share of non-fiction books but haven’t read a novel in years. I’m afraid I don’t have the patience. But I admire folks who do.
Speaking of books, you could have READ Mathilda…
It doesn’t take patience to read a novel; just a taste for fiction. if you don’t enjoy it, nothing wrong with that….but you should still read some of them in high school, for a good foundation.
I just thought it was humorous that bud is quoting a movie, adapted from a book, about wasting time reading a book when there’s movies/tv available to watch. Roald Dahl would have also found that humorous.
I’m glad I could amuse someone. My wife complains that my sense of humor is way too dry.
Wait, you mean you are really a right Wong ideologue?
Wing…
Though Wong is kind of funny…..
A foundation that you don’t use? Sort of like building a basement for a house and then walking away… waste of time. Perhaps some people don’t get anything out of the selections that are mandatory in high school because they are boring. It would be better to encourage reading versus mandating a set of books that are “important”.
You cannot know that you didn’t use it. There’s no control “Doug” who never read, or more importantly, thought about classic literature….
That’s the biggest copout I’ve ever heard. That would suggest that you can’t tell the value of ANY education or any experience in general. Everything is the same.
The value of education is the application of education. I have not applied any of the classic literature education I have received. I also found it boring and hated all the time I wasted on it. What I learned from the experience is that I wouldn’t force anyone else to go through it.
Yeah, and all the math haters, and other school haters who swear they never use their educations should have just dropped out of first grade….
You use math. You don’t use Shakespeare. But I would agree that schools waste too much time as well teaching math that is not used.
Isn’t it amazing that pretty much everyone is exposed to all the same cookie cutter English education yet it doesn’t create any demand for the type of literature once the mandatory requirements are completed? People want to read Fifty Shades of Grey, Harry Potter, The Girl With The Dragan Tattoo, Game of Thrones, John Grisham, etc. etc, People in general don’t talk about classic literature. There’s a simple reason for that – it’s not interesting or relevant to the majority of people.
I’m more interested in teaching students HOW to read, not WHAT to read. I watched my three kids go thru high school with the same list of dull books that fail to inspire or educate. It’s pure “read these pages and then the teacher will tell you what they REALLY mean”. The Scarlet Letter, A Tale of Two Cities, Frankenstein, Chaucer, The Iliad, Odsyssey… stuff that few teenagers in 2013 can get anything from.
Here’s the results of a recent survey of the the books people pretend to have read the most :
http://bookriot.com/2013/07/17/top-20-books-you-pretend-to-have-read/#.Ue84UoukuVQ.twitter
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen
Ulysses by James Joyce
Moby-Dick by Herman Melville
War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy
The Bible
1984 by George Orwell
The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien
The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald
Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy
Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger
Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace
Catch-22 by Joseph Heller
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee
Fifty Shades of Grey by E.L. James
Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte
Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky
Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte
Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
Harry Potter (series) by J.K. Rowling
A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens
Let’s see, using that list:
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen — read it more than once
Ulysses by James Joyce — never read it, but have read Dubliners and Portrait of the Artist
Moby-Dick by Herman Melville — started it multiple times, enjoy the opening, but always bog down after they go to sea, which is odd. Got an A+ on the six-weeks (essay) test, since we had discussed it to death
War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy — nope
The Bible — not all the way through, to my shame
1984 by George Orwell — read it many times; it’s awesome
The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien — read it as an adult, enjoyed it, didn’t get as into it as people who start reading it younger
The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald — read it
Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy — I think I was supposed to read it in school, didn’t get far into it
Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger — read it, but it’s not a cult thing for me
Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace — not even familiar with it
Catch-22 by Joseph Heller — read it over and over and wrote many essays about it in school
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee — read it several times
Fifty Shades of Grey by E.L. James — no interest in ever reading it
Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte — nope
Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky — oh, yeah. Probably THE great novel, next to Huck Finn
Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte — read it a couple of times
Great Expectations by Charles Dickens — I THINK I read it in school
Harry Potter (series) by J.K. Rowling — the first three books or so
A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens — nope, which everyone tells me is a crime
Two titles seemed really out of place on that list — Infinite Jest (of which I had not even heard) and Fifty Shades of Grey.
To paraphrase Sean Connery in The Untouchables — who would claim to have read those, who had not?
Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen – nope
Ulysses by James Joyce – nope
Moby-Dick by Herman Melville – In high school
War and Peace by Leo Tolstoy – didn’t finish
The Bible – parts of it
1984 by George Orwell – in high school
The Lord of the Rings by J.R.R. Tolkien – yup!
The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald – high school
Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy – nope
Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger – in high school
Infinite Jest by David Foster Wallace – nope
Catch-22 by Joseph Heller – in high school
To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee – 9th grade
Fifty Shades of Grey by E.L. James – nope
Jane Eyre by Charlotte Bronte – read Wuthering Heights instead
Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky – yup
Wuthering Heights by Emily Bronte – in high school
Great Expectations by Charles Dickens – middle school
Harry Potter (series) by J.K. Rowling – yup
A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens – middle school
Parnassus Books is pretty well known among bookshop operators — because it was a start-up AFTER the big-box bookstores killed the MomandPop bookstores in Memphis, and then went out of business themselves, leaving Memphis bookstoreless.
Er, Parnassus is in Nashville; believe me, there’s a difference.
Of course, Anne Patchett was already a well-known author when she started Parnassus Books. It helps if you have a following wind when you get into another line of business.
I was a bit bemused that Brad doesn’t know who Ann Patchett is; clearly, he doesn’t read recent stuff.
I certainly do not. How could I? There’s so much in line ahead of it.
First, I haven’t touched the classics — even translated into English. I have a copy of The Odyssey (or is it the Iliad) on a shelf downstairs, and haven’t found the time.
I still have some of Shakespeare’s works to read. I haven’t touched Faulkner since giving up on him in college. Beyond Crime and Punishment and Brothers Karamazov, Dostoevsky remains unexplored. The only Fitzgerald I’ve read is The Great Gatsby and a book of short stories, long ago. The only thing by Steinbeck I ever made it through was Of Mice and Men a retelling of Malory’s Morte d’Arthur — and I won’t let myself see the classic film version of Grapes of Wrath until I’ve read the book.
I’ve read some Conrad, but not enough.
I’ve read nothing by Proust, Hugo or any of those other foreign coves. As for slightly less-well-known writers who were alive in the time of Hemingway and Fitzgerald — Ford Madox Ford, John Dos Passos — fuggedaboudit.
Oh, and for those who think I only think of dead white guys, allow me to say that I feel bad that all I’ve read of Austen is Pride and Prejudice, which I thought was great, and while I really enjoyed Wuthering Heights, I’ve read nothing else by the Brontes.
I could go on and on, but this litany is starting to depress me.
As for living writers… I’ve very much enjoyed the past work of John le Carre and Martin Cruz Smith, but they haven’t produced anything I really liked recently. As for some of the more “literary” authors of the past generation, I’ve found Updike and John Irving highly disappointing. I couldn’t get into Salman Rushdie’s stuff at all, though I did enjoy meeting him and hearing his lecture at USC several years back.
That’s fiction. I have read and enjoyed a number of current authors writing biography and other forms of history, but recent fiction hasn’t interested me.
Given the fantastic stuff that I know I’ll probably never get to, I’m afraid Ann Patchett isn’t near the top of my list, or even on it. I’ve heard of some of her works — Bel Canto, Run, The Patron Saint of Liars — but her name has never registered on me, possibly because I’ve never made a note to myself to read them.
Were I to live 1,000 years, I might eventually get to her. But I don’t think that’s going to happen.
I don’t want to leave y’all with the impression that I don’t get to current stuff because I’m so busy with great stuff from the past.
The dirty little secret is that I spend far, far, far, far too much of the limited time life affords me for reading in a rather wasteful exercise — rereading the stuff I’ve enjoyed in the past, rather than broadening my horizons reading stuff that is new to me.
On the high end, I’ve probably read Crime and Punishment two or three times (in chunks at a time), and the Grand Inquisitor portion of Brothers Karamazov at least as many times — but haven’t gotten to The Idiot. And I’ve lost count on my favorites among Mark Twain’s books.
But truth be told, I’m far more likely to reread Patrick O’Brian, or far more lowbrow stuff such as Stranger in a Strange Land.
A glance at the really dogeared books on my shelves would not do me credit…
Lately I’m more into Dr. Seuss.
I have not read Ann Patchett, yet, though her books are on my shelf, but she’s pretty well known, Brad….
My husband loves reading on his ipad. I can’t stand it, though I understand the appeal of having multiple books in one package. I don’t read much fiction. I generally prefer thick, footnoted history tomes, which is why I’m not reading much while chasing a 6yo. However, I keep buying books, waiting for the day when I can read in peace! My son LOVES bookstores. He knows if there’s one thing he can talk Mommy into buying, it’s a book. Or two or three.
I agree with Kevin’s comment. I’m often frustrated at the lack of the classics in the physical stores.
Powell’s Books in Portland, Ore.
Best place every for a dreary, rainy climate. One could get lost in there and spend days upon days just reading one’s way through the stacks – randomly. If anyone visits PDX, stop by Powells with a few hours blocked off.
Been there, done that.
I loaned my paperback copy of Frank Herbert’s “Dune” to a friend. He said that he was reading it in the bathtub when it fell in the water.
I bought another copy of Dune and also bought a few backups in the years.
Yeah, me, too. I don’t know how many times I’ve read it.
But let me say that the sequels were not worth my time.
I am Paul.
Paul I am.
Do you like the Spice Melange?
I do not like the Spice Melange, I do not like it, Paul I am.
Would you like it here, or there?
I would not like it here or there, I would not like it anywhere.
Would you like it with the Fremen? Would you like it in a great house?
I would not like it with the Fremen, I would not like it in a great house.
Would you like it on Arrakis? Would you like it with a sandworm?
I would not like it on Arrakis, I would not like it with a sandworm. Not with the Fremen, not in a great house, not on a heighliner, not with the Kwisatz Haderach, I would not like it here or there, I do not like it anywhere.
and they say literature education is useless…
Let’s have a little talk about tweetle beetles….
You’d BETTER like the spice, Paul. You’re addicted to it…
You do not like spice.
SO you say.
Try it! Try it!
And you may.
Try spice and you may I say.
Paul!
If you will let me be,
I will try spice.
You will see.