Earlier today I wrote something about the contrast that was expected between Elizabeth Warren’s speech and Bill Clinton’s. That was certainly dead on. She gave one of those speeches full of resentments and blame, the kind that makes me dislike political parties so much.
And then Bill Clinton gave a speech that, while lifting the crowd in the arena to their feet, talked right on through them and to all of America, making the case for Barack Obama as no one has ever made it before, in a way that was a feel-good celebration of politics and democracy and this country and the things that make it great.
I can’t remember the last time I heard a political speech this good. Here are my thoughts, via Twitter, as it unfolded. You can see my enthusiasm build from the moment the former president started talking. The Tweets that follow, starting at 9:29 p.m., are mine, except where otherwise indicated:
- The most warmly positive, uplifting speech I’ve heard tonight so far was from the sister from Nuns on the Bus. It was beatific…
- Back in the day, when there were 3 networks covering gavel to gavel, I seem to recall less gab and more voting; less show, more action.
- Wow, they weren’t kidding about this woman [Warren]. Who wrote her speech? Huey Long? https://bradwarthen.com/?p=17980
- amhistorymuseum @amhistorymuseum Abraham Lincoln was the first presidential candidate to distribute his campaign portrait all over the country. #campaigncollecting
- … Which you wouldn’t automatically assume would have been to his advantage…
- Billy’s doing his duty, actually talking about Obama rather than himself. How about that?
- Good line about “cool on the inside”…
- “Business and government working together… ” That’s a welcome contrast to Warren’s anti-biz, populist rant…
- He’s giving the Third Way a hard sell, and doing it well…
- They’re not quite sure what to make of Clinton’s lauding of Republicans for the good things they’ve done…
- The speech Bill Clinton is giving fulfills the Democrats’ best hopes (and stills their worst loose-cannon fears). This is impressive.
- Bill Clinton is reminding American what it’s like to be a Democrat, a winning Democrat, whose politics aren’t based in resentment…
- Maybe President Obama should let Bill Clinton do the speech TOMMOROW night, too…
- He may have lost weight, but he hasn’t lost his touch. The Comeback Kid still has it. Maybe some of it will rub off.
- No, Bill! Don’t say “listen to me…” Shades of the Lewinsky denial. You’re on a roll! Don’t go off course…
- When Bill Clinton’s talking, it almost sounds like it would be fun to be a Democrat…
- Warren Bolton @BoltonWarren If nothing else, this will have Obama juiced for tomorrow for sure. Can he deliver?
- I don’t know, but Bill sure is teeing it up for him. The key to what he’s doing is the confidence, and the sheer joy.
- He [Obama] just needs to come out cool on the outside, and burning inside for America…
- Bill is the first person speaking positively to independents tonight — except for maybe Sister Simone…
- I’ve never heard anyone make the case for Barack Obama this well.
- The thing about Clinton is, he convinces you he really understands the wonkish details (mainly because he does), and is really INTO them.
- “It takes some brass.” His second best line of the speech. The best was the “cool on the outside” thing…
- He knows he’s got them. He can feel it. He can slow it down, or speed it up, and they’re right there with him every second…
- John O’Connor @johnroconnor I really only needed Clinton 101, not 201 and 315
- This is the graduate seminar course. This is Bill Clinton under a yellow sun, with all his powers.
- One of the many things Bill Clinton understands is the importance of talking to the millions of us who are NOT in that room.
- Bill knows how to tear the Republicans a new one — or two — without making you think he hates them…
- Warren Bolton @BoltonWarren This is where the preacher, with the congregation firmly in his hands, says “I’ about to take my seat.” Then 15 minutes later …
- Now he’s schoolin’ ’em on ‘rithmetic…
- No, don’t shake your finger at us, Bill. It evokes bad stuff. Stick with the good stuff…
- This speech is the most generous and selfless thing that Bill Clinton has done in his whole life.
- Bet on America… we always come back… Man, he’s hitting every note, and hitting it just right…
It was amazing. He’s just that good. And I say that as the editor who presided over an editorial board that was tied as first in the country to call on him to resign after he admitted lying to us. But he was always really, really good at this, and I don’t just mean in ways that were good for him. It’s actually good for the country to hear a speech like this. So much of politics these days is depressing, dispiriting. We all needed a lift like this.
Some were complaining that the speech was too long. No. Bill Clinton has given some of the longest, most tedious speeches most of us can remember. But tonight he wasn’t indulging himself. Tonight he was giving.